By: Annna [2001-01-29]

I Hate Blackboard

using my bully pulpit


yeah well it took me like three minutes

Sorry to our regulars (all six of you), but this is just me rabbiting on about the latest highly specific annoyance in my life over which I have no control. Sean will probably have something interesting on Wednesday, or we'll have a wake for the King of Prussia or something. To anyone from the U of O, read on:

The University of Oregon has been slowly integrating the Web into its classes. It used to be that I'd sign up for my classes, then get a few straggling emails telling me I was subscribed to various email lists. The lists would get a couple of emails a term, usually along the lines of:

okay, I think I have it wroking now.

The assignment for Wednesday is chapter 6,
not chapter 16 as stated in the syllabus.
Have a nice day!! :)


Every now and then we'd have an active list. Sometimes the teacher would send out discussion questions. Sometimes we'd be required to post a message a week on the reading. Sometimes that insane girl (required by law to be in every class I take) who spends 15 minutes of class talking about phallic symbols and her own personal numerological take on the universe would figure out how to work her email program and send bizarre, disjointed ramblings out into the ether for all of us to shudder at.

But usually I'd just forget about the list until next semester, when I remembered to unsubscribe myself as the messages from the next class came in.

The lists were useful when needed, invisible when not needed. Along with a minimal class website listing syllabus and office hours, it was the perfect system.

So of course they decided to change it. The Blackboard system is akin to the heinous UBB software - a crawling coding chaos infecting systems across the land. Via an unintuitive interface of tabs and folders (how cute!), it makes everything several times harder. You can look at it here as a guest; though you can't see any courses, you can still get a view of how fundamentally irritating it is.

First off, I have to log in with name and password. This may say more about me than it does about the system, but that's just one psychic hurdle too many. This is Intro to the English Major, not State Secrets 499 (restrictions: must not be commie bastard, must have own bulletproof briefcase). I realize I can check my grades from the interface, but how about deleting that feature and allowing free access? Anyone who wants to check their grades daily is probably too busy making sure the iron isn't on/hands are clean/hands are clean/hands are clean/HANDS ARE NOT CLEAN to actually do it.

Being encouraged to check it daily (without any idea of when the admins will update, if at all) might actually work if I could just put the site on my bookmarks and visit it with an idle click:

*click*
No new Pokey.
*click*
No Bobbins.
*click*
No new sites on Portal of Evil.
*click*
No new English assignments . Sigh.
*click*
No updates on McSweeney's.
*click*

as opposed to:

*click*
type type type TAB type type type
*click*
*click*
*click*
ponder navigation buttons
*click*
OH GOD BLACKBOARD SYSTEM WHY DO YOU MOCK ME THUS?!
sobbing, sound of potato chip packet being torn open

Variable reward schedules may work for pigeons, Mr. Skinner, but like any good 3-year-old I want some damn consistency.

Once logged in, what's on Blackboard? The syllabus and some discussion questions, the first of which was passed out during the first class. Hey, I ain't no perfesser or nuthin', but which makes more sense:

1. Syllabus and all the discussion questions are typed up, printed and bound in a packet affordable to everyone.

2. Syllabus is printed out, discussion questions are put in an obscure corner of an unnavigable website. One week at a time. This sure keeps people from reading ahead or having all their knowledge objectives in one handy place, all right!

Option #2 also means that in order to only print out one week's questions (because you have the last week's, natch), you have to copy the text into a word processor, reformat it so it prints without screwy margins all over the place, then either print it out of your own ink cartridge or schlep over to the computer lab. That's way more convenient than just buying a packet.

It occurs to me that our esteemed professor is probably feeding us the requirements in dribs and drabs because - shock! horror! - she hasn't written all the reading questions in advance. Hey, I'm fine with that. If I weren't such a procrastinatrix myself I wouldn't be taking Intro to the English Major in my senior year. But how about making a normal webpage, with a link to the syllabus and a link to each week's questions?

I realize that another attraction of the Blackboard system is that someone who isn't Web-literate can bang together a webpage in seconds, but a class website wouldn't even have to be in HTML! The whole thing could just be a bare root directory displaying .txt documents and I'd be ever so much happier. The people in class now are the people who grew up on Usenet and k-rad BBSes. Wait for a few years to get flashy for the Web-bred people, okay?

But you know what would be an even better way to keep students up to date with the class than either an overdeveloped webpage or a bare bones one? A place that every student would check every day? A service that everyone who doesn't have severe problems already knows how to access and does so at every opportunity? An Internet application whose only prerequisite is knowing how to type and press "Send"?

Their email, that's where. Set up a list with open registration - hell, it's a one-line email, I'll subscribe myself! - and send out the questions to everyone. They'll print better, convey a sense of immediacy, and nobody will be able to say "I didn't check Blackboard today."

Sometimes the simplest solutions are the best.
same class [2001-01-29 00:08:35] Annna
This is the same professor who puts up a question on the overhead projector for us to answer every day (basically a way to check who's in class). That'd be only marginally more annoying than having us write our names on a roll sheet, were it not typed IN ALL CAPS. IN AN ENGLISH CLASS. AM I ON BIZARRO WORLD OR SOMETHING? IT'S LIKE BEING IN AN UNHOLY CROSS BETWEEN JERKCITY AND POKEY THE PENGUIN.

This is all, of course, part of my grand scheme to alienate the entire English department of this great university, one by one.
Nailbombs [2001-01-29 10:05:08] vicarious
I wish I had a website to check to see if I had regular people. Do you know, I visit this site almost every day? And when I don't see anything new, I re-read the archives. *sob* My... my life... it extends before me like a Massive Attack album.

Anyway. I wish we had a blackboard type system at my college. All we have is the 'Intranet', a half-assed attempt at a good network. WE HAVE A CRAB ON THE HOMEPAGE, FOR THE LOVE OF GOD: http://www.tavycoll.rmplc.co.uk/
(I am doing A-Levels, btw)

Just for the record, I didn't actually check out the blackboard site you posted. Maybe I should have done...
Don't bother [2001-01-29 10:59:49] Annna
It's just bland and frustrating to deal with, not outwardly evil unless you use it a lot.

It's not like it's covered with background images of dead babies and every click causes Java box within Java box. It's a more insidious evil.
Black boards [2001-01-29 13:34:15] Chip
Yeah I just noticed the blackboard this term, It was a requirement for this Political scince class I took to post on one twice. I droped the class cause I don't need that kind of crap, if we already meet a few times a week and then we also have e-mail, office hours and discustion group; how much interaction do we really need. teaching at the UofO is already sort of a shame what with the way Professers just dump everything on the graduate students it seems like if they want reading questions they should just MAKE THEM UP BEFORE THE CLASS THEY WANT THEM DUE. good god I hate my self I have no real skills a history degree is a shame I've misspelled so many words in this artical and I'm attending a shame of a liberal arts school thats stead fast in giving me an education out of the 80's sucide only way out must ditch my life in a hight art hail of bullets...so much pain so much pain
chalk [2001-01-29 13:55:00] vicarious
I don't know. It might not have any dead babies, but it does smack of evil. BBC2 kind of evil.
Hmmm. [2001-01-29 17:16:01] Sean
Background covered with dead babies, and every click brings up JavaScript popups.... I think it's time to re-design this site.
Another couple of things about Blackboard [2001-01-30 00:34:33] Annna
On the login screen, after I type in my name and password, I can't tab to the Submit button. Hitting tab just returns the cursor to the location bar, so when I hit enter instinctively it reloads and I have to type it all in again.

There's also a way to set up an email list within Blackboard, but although it emails out to the whole class, the only way to reply to said emails is through the website. Whoever designed this giant HTML scuzzball must not have ever had to use it.

Why does this bother me so much?
University of Otago (NZ) also infected [2001-01-30 19:12:48] Craig Timpany
My experiences with Blackboard haven't been too bad, but I imagine this is because my course is largely technical and not had any 'discussions'.

My attitude has softened up by the way a quarter of my COMP102 grade depended on a Javascript test through blackboard. (restricted to a particular comp lab, of course)

I liked the way I wandered in for an hour and a half test, that people around me had been freaking out and cramming for, without any sort of preparation, and wandered out after spending 10 minutes clicking boxes bearing an 85% mark.

Instantly marked. Pretty strong positive reinforcement.
Well, tests are nice.... [2001-01-30 19:34:58] Annna
Yeah, I had a class (Business 101) that had one redeeming feature: the tests were online. The less time spent in the Business building complex, the better.

So I suppose it's just a question of using the wrong tool for the job. When your only tool is a shovel, every problem looks like the back of some guy's head. When your only tool - or, rather, your shiniest new tool - is Blackboard, every class looks like it should subscribe.
Damned Blackboard. [2001-02-18 03:18:52] Skeeter
Blackboard has the smell of evil. I actually was bitching to James just the other day about how annoying it is that I can't bookmark Blackboard in such a way that I could click said bookmark and visit the site *without* having to enter my stupid login EVERY SINGLE TIME.

The thing that really bugs me is that they created this horrendous system to release any and all profs from having to learn basic HTML. IT'S NOT THAT HARD! They don't even have to really *learn* HTML anymore either, because it's even *more* mind-numbingly easy to figure out some crappy WYSIWYG editor. These are supposed to be educated people here!

Semi-related tangent: One of my multimedia profs recently used Blackboard to post an online quiz. He sent out an e-mail saying that it was up, which I promptly forgot about, because the only things from the e-mail that really registered with me were "quiz" and "Friday". Does it seem wrong to anyone else that you get online quizzes thrown at you at random, despite the fact that it is NOT an online class? I have to go to your lame-ass lectures, mister, so if I have to take a quiz, then I want some questions printed on pink sheets of paper, damnit!
Inconsistant (Colorado School of Mines) [2006-12-13 10:42:54] Jeremy
Granted, this should have died a *long* time ago, but mines has it now too... and it is a deeply evil and sinister program in every way. It's basically microsoft on PCP. There are a million ways to accomplish the same task, but unlike microsoft, they all lead to a different result.

So we, have classes that put the syllabus in the course documents folder of some class... then others that put it in the class info... and others that post it in announcements... then others that accidently make it a test... then others that email it to us.. then others that just loose it into the heartless soul of blackboard.

Then we have those crazy professors who lock the class out of registration but don't want to sign us all up and start posting our assignments there.

Then every so often a professor finds a new feature of blackboard which makes you have to learn a whole new acid-trip induced version of browser navigation to a part of the site that should not exist.

I hate that damn system with every single bone, muscle, organ, and general atom in my being. I vote directory browsing of txt files and mailing lists as well.... or better yet... just assume everyone in a class was smart enough to either be there or know how to get any announcements or assignments from the class another way.

Anyway... Die blackboard.
All content copyright original authors; contact them for reprint permission.